South Africa’s Asylum Law Reforms: Constitutional Rights, Immigration Control and a New Registration System
October 12, 2026
South Africa is preparing changes to asylum registration following a Constitutional Court judgment challenging restrictions on access to refugee protection.
Background: What Was the Previous Position?
Amendments to South Africa’s Refugees Act, effective from 1 January 2020, introduced additional requirements for people seeking asylum. Those entering without appropriate documentation, or not complying with prescribed procedures, could be required to demonstrate good cause before being permitted to lodge a claim. These restrictions were challenged because they could prevent access to the asylum process before a protection claim was assessed.
The Constitutional Court Judgment
On 7 July 2026, the Constitutional Court delivered judgment in Scalabrini Centre of Cape Town and Another v Minister of Home Affairs and Others. The Court declared provisions of the asylum framework unconstitutional, including restrictions linked to the good-cause screening requirement. Irregular entry should not, by itself, prevent access to procedures for assessing an asylum claim. The judgment does not automatically grant refugee status or permanent residence; claims still require individual assessment.
Government Response and Implementation
Following the judgment, the Department of Home Affairs issued an operational directive on 28 September 2026. The government subsequently reported difficulties at Refugee Reception Offices. On 9 October 2026, the Department withdrew the directive while considering alternative arrangements. Withdrawal of an administrative directive does not reverse the Constitutional Court’s judgment.
Proposed Registration System
On 11 October 2026, the government announced plans for a structured registration and appointment system, targeted for 10 November 2026. Individuals would register an intention to seek asylum and receive an appointment at a Refugee Reception Office. An acknowledgement of registration would not itself amount to refugee recognition or an asylum visa. The government also indicated that it would seek further judicial guidance. As at 12 October 2026, the proposed system was not yet operational.
Legal and Practical Implications
Access to asylum procedures must be considered alongside immigration-control requirements. Implementing court decisions may demand significant administrative changes. Crucially, registering an asylum claim and obtaining refugee status are distinct legal steps. Migrants and advisers should follow current official instructions during the transition.
Saclan International Perspective
South Africa’s experience illustrates the balance between constitutional and international refugee-protection obligations and the practical administration of immigration systems. The judgment concerns access to the asylum process; the proposed measures concern how that access will be administered. Their effect will depend on the final framework and implementation.